George Lucas made one big mistake Star Wars the prequel trilogy ignored the lesson from the original trilogy that movies shouldn’t be directed by themselves. The Star Wars The prequel trilogy received a mixed reception upon its initial release, although its reputation has rightfully improved over the years. Still, it remains valuable to look back and examine what made the prequels so disappointing.
Although Lucas insisted that he was pursuing his vision, even he had to pay attention to the reactions of the fans. This led to several twists in the storytelling, for example; Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace introduced concepts such as midi-choruses and a chosen prophecy, but Lucas chose not to focus on these, as noted in interviews with Paul Duncan. Star Wars Archives: Episodes I-III 1999-2005 – it will be like this “gentle“But the story wasn’t the only problem; in fact, the main problem may have come from the franchise itself.
The original rule of George Lucas’ trilogy means that he did not direct all 3 prequels.
Looking back at the original trilogy, Lucas took a more hands-on route, staying in San Francisco while the film was being shot in Europe. Although Lucas had rough cuts, he was not directly involved in the filming. In 1979, Gary Kurtz, who directed all three original trilogy films, said The New York Times this is completely intentional. “It’s hard to look over another director’s shoulder,“He watched.”The temptation is always to say, “I wouldn’t do that.” Luckily, George isn’t too interested in directing – he hasn’t directed a movie since Star Wars. He prefers to edit. We always felt that a different director should tell each story. You get a different emphasis and approach that way.“
Kurtz’s words make perfect sense, as each of the three original trilogy films are slightly different in their direction, but still feel like they’re part of the same universe. This keeps the audience engaged and allows different personalities to make their mark Star Wars. However, this did not happen for the prequel trilogy, as George Lucas directed all three films. It’s a little odd that Lucas put himself in this position for three movies, knowing that Kurtz Lucas said he didn’t like directing. In fact, George Lucas did not direct a single film among the first films Star Wars film (later renamed A new hope) and Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace.
It’s interesting to speculate why Lucas chose to break his original trilogy rule and direct the prequels. Perhaps the explanation is that over the years he has felt a growing sense of ownership Star Wars and sought to create a clear vision of it. It also matches the changes they made with special editions.
Would the prequels have been better if George Lucas hadn’t directed them?
If Lucas hadn’t directed all three films, it’s hard to say whether the prequel trilogy would have been better received when it was released. They would be methodologically different and there could be wider variations; the actors admitted that they had a hard time delivering the dialogue to Lucas because they felt themselves Star Wars It belonged to Him, and they saw themselves as simply carrying out His revelation. But it’s worth noting that Lucas’ prequel trilogy wasn’t bad, it just disappointed audiences who didn’t live up to their expectations. Regardless of who is in charge, the answer is likely to be the same.
It’s remarkable that George Lucas decided to step back into the director’s chair for the prequels, despite the director’s different take on the original trilogy. Lucas was basically just someone who wrote and produced afterwards A new hope, and his willingness to direct the prequels shows how passionate he is about Anakin Skywalker’s origin. It’s worth noting, however, that the subsequent trilogy abandoned this approach and took on multiple directors – with mixed results. It is possible Star Wars A finer balance is needed between vision and different directors.